I have these for a couple of weeks and really like them. They are a bear to get on and a gnarly beast to get off for the first twenty times because of the tall stovepipe tops. Once they are on they fit snugly but well and are pretty comfortable. They are amazing to ride in and really work with stirrups well. They work better with jeans tucked in and are really designed for that. I would not recommend walking on concrete all day processing cattle as the leather sole does not provide any cushion. I do recommend the 4s heel as a good middle ground between the tall 5s and smaller shorter heels.
They are great ranch boots and are made well, as well as having a custom boot feeling about them.